Let Starmer Carry the Failure. Let Labour Carry the Renewal
The calls for Keir Starmer to resign are understandable. Labour has taken a serious beating in the local elections. The government looks exhausted less than two years after winning a landslide. Reform is pulling voters away on the right. The Greens are pulling voters away on the left. Starmer’s personal authority is badly damaged, and recent polling suggests the electorate has fragmented in a way that should terrify anybody hoping for a straightforward Labour recovery.
So the obvious response is to change the leader. I think that would be a mistake.